Being an IT guy, Wired is one of my favorite magazines. Luckily the August issue arrived before the mail stoppage (I am not sure what to call it when a country stops inbound mail). I opened the magazine only to discover that there is an article on the tech exec's visit to Iraq. The DoS invited several technology executives (Google, Twitter, Facebook, AT&T, etc) to Iraq a couple of months ago. The article is fantastic and directly addresses the issues we face in re-building the Iraqi economy. I highly recommend purchasing this month's issue, for my female readers Brad Pitt is on the cover...
We have a saying in Iraq, the Good Idea Fairy is alive and well. One of the things I have discovered is that both the US and Iraqi Governments are top heavy. We have numerous executives, generals and ambassadors making strategic plans and creating directives. However, there is no execution layer. In the US, we have directors, senior managers, analysts and engineers to make ideas reality. In Iraq, that entire layer of professionals is absent. So the country abounds with good ideas such as this visit but with little or no carry through. The article is so insightful that I have decided to comment on some of the article's highlights:
"Can Iraq be saved by meetups, tweets, blogs and YouTube videos?" - No, we are working to establish basic communications. I am typing this blog on a 160K connection (remember dial up?). A major win is getting the banks and government on the same network. Maybe someday applications will help but not for a long time.
"Cohen's fear is that taking a bunch of Web 2.0 suits into a nation shattered by war will be seen as an absurd boondogle" - I would say that is a pretty accurate description to most of us on the ground in Iraq.
"...as new markets go, Iraq falls somewhere between Antarctica and Somalia in desirability" - Iraq NEEDS foreign investment but does not WANT foreign firms. There are many international groups as well as the US, UK, Japan, EU and others that are working hard to encourage investment but it is an extremely difficult job. Iraq is afraid of foreign entities taking over but they desperately need to develop their infrastructure. The ongoing credit crunch does not help either.
"Businesspeople and even embassy staff often list multiple mobile phone numbers on their cards, one for each wireless network." - Imagine if your Sprint phone would not allow you to call anyone with an AT&T phone. The two cell phone providers are so competitive that they intentionally bar calls from their competitor. You think phone customer service is bad in the US, try no customer service. Go to www.asiacell.com and click on a couple of links to get a taste of their customer service. The website is a great example of a "good idea" but with no follow through.
"Most Iraqis use prepaid phones, because with limited banking infrastructure in the country, billing systems don't work. Neither do credit cards." - This is true but this is what my team is working on. We have made enormous strides in this area but this project will take years to complete. It could be done much faster with international investment and a robust private sector, Iraq has neither. Oh, and one more funny story. Last month one of the Iraqi cell phone providers arbitrarily locked out several thousand SIM cards. One day your phone works, the next day is doesn't. They did get it fixed but it took a few days.
"But when Heiferman asks them (Baghdad University students) what they want for their future, no one envisions creating wealth and innovation in the private sector. Instead, they want to work for the government. They want job security and pensions. This makes the Silicon Valley group crazy." - As an third party observer I love watching the interactions between the socialist Iraqis and the free market US representatives. Iraq is the last frontier for many Republicans (very little has changed between the Bush and OBama administrations). I don't think you could find two groups more philosophically opposed to one another. Generally speaking the Iraqi's don't "get" free enterprise and capitalism. The entire country has spent the last 30 years under a command driven economy in relative isolationism, they do not know anything else.
The article concludes with an ending I have seen so often in Iraq, with a compromise. The trip started with the idea of rolling out social networking to Iraq, resulting in a social transformation. Instead, the Museum of Iraq will get a website, some students will get laptops and an Iraqi official has started using Twitter. This is not the desired result dreamt of around a conference table in Washington but it is progress. Progress in Iraq is accomplished through small bumps and nudges applied at the right time. Progress is slow but at least it is progress.
Read the article, it is an accurate picture of the Iraq that I see on a daily basis.